The Barstool Effect: Local Businesses Buzzing From Portnoy’s Pizza Reviews
One of Dave Portnoy's recent pizza-tasting excursions took him to Poughkeepsie's Pipinelli’s, where business is booming. Photo by Joe Logan '27
Thirteen years ago, Dave Portnoy, owner of Barstool Sports, posted his first pizza review. Portnoy’s search for the perfect New York style slice has now brought him to over 1,100 locations and most recently, the Hudson Valley.
The latest tour saw Portnoy and his crew drive from Saratoga to New York City, making stops at Pipinelli’s Pizza Parlor in Poughkeepsie and Mommò Pizza Shop in Fishkill. The restaurants received scores of 7.6 and 8.2 respectively, each ranking among the top-rated reviews.
To some restaurant owners, a visit from Portnoy is a dream come true. For others, the popularity of the company creates public credibility for great food. For Alex Serroukas, owner of Pipinelli’s, it's a little bit of both.
“It’s pretty much every pizzeria owner’s dream to have Dave Portnoy come in and give a phenomenal score,” said Serroukas. “We had a lot of publicity prior to his arrival, so many people were tagging him that he came to the area specifically for us.”
Portnoy’s stop at Pipinelli’s also posed a challenge for the restaurant's owner - it was his first stop and he arrived shortly after the restaurant opened.
“I’m actually lucky that we got a 7.6 because he placed his order at 11 a.m., when we opened,” Serroukas said. “The ovens aren’t rolling yet… if it was an hour later I think things would have been even better.”
Pipinelli’s had seen an uptick in business over recent months anyway, with social media influencers like Druski stopping in and bringing added attention. The pizza has been so sought after that a billionaire (who remains anonymous) even had a helicopter fly into a local airport to pick up five pies according to Serroukas.
For Serroukas, it isn’t all about the newfound popularity, as the roots of the business and his own motivation are tied to the local community.
“You can only reach so many people, but it’s really nice to have a lot of new faces, local faces who are now regular customers,” Serroukas said.
Serroukas grew up down the block from his future business, going to school right across the street. The building used to be Cozzy’s Place, also a pizzeria, which caught fire and sat vacant for years. Serroukas and his business partner purchased the building and named it after his grandfather, filling a void for pizza shops on Hooker Avenue.
Family roots are a common theme for these pizzerias. Luca Dombre, owner of Mommò Pizza Shop, is a third-generation pizza maker, but the first in his family to make pizza in the United States. Mommò started out as a food truck and remained that way for nearly four years. This August, Dombre opened a brick-and-mortar location in Fishkill.
Born near the Ferrari factory in Northern Italy, it’s no surprise that Dombre sets the industry standard when it comes to pizza. Known for their traditional Neapolitan slices, Mommò’s New York style received an 8.2, tied for 88th on Portnoy’s extensive list. Unlike Pipinelli’s, Mommò wasn’t as prepared for the publicity that came with such a high rating.
“After Portnoy came, we had several days where we sold out,” said Dombre. “The very first weekend after the review we wrapped a couple hours before [regular closing].”
The dough is a fresh sourdough starter that requires 24 hours to rest. Not knowing what to expect, with a small kitchen and just two chefs, the only way to match the demand would be to sacrifice quality, a compromise that Dombre refuses to make.
“We could have made same-day dough, but when we run out we run out.” He added, “We want people to understand that we don’t compromise quality for money. I’m completely against that.”
When he moved to the United States, Dombre says that he brought “the knowledge of my heritage” as his main value. He refers to his product as “the natural synthesis of the traditions that have shaped my journey.”
The ties to tradition led to a cultural clash for the native Italian. “In Italy the way we eat pizza is you go to a pizzeria and you get your own personal pie,” he said. “Here, especially in New York, the approach is more the slice - but I like the challenge of getting out of the comfort zone and saying, let’s try and come up with a good recipe for something that people are used to here.”
Dombre has certainly risen to the occasion, along with the high rating, Portnoy went on to say that Mommò’s “is as good as you can get from this type of oven.” Dombre was humbled by the experience and says that he’s happy to see the direction that his business is moving in after just a few months.
While both Serroukas and Dombre were proud of their ratings, the praise came as a surprise to neither. Both owners cite the local, fresh ingredients as a primary contributor in the quality of their products.
In a business as unpredictable as the food industry, Dave Portnoy, the Barstool brand and social media at large have made sure that Pipinelli’s and Mommò are set to soar.